• Skip to primary navigation
  • Skip to main content
  • Skip to primary sidebar
  • Home
  • About
  • Shop
  • Contact
OMG! Yummy
  • Recipes
  • Cookbook!
  • Tasting Jerusalem
  • Jewish Recipes
menu icon
go to homepage
search icon
Homepage link
  • Home
  • About
  • Recipe Index
  • Cookbook!
  • Tasting Jerusalem
  • Jewish Recipes
  • Shop
  • Contact
    • Facebook
    • Instagram
    • Pinterest
    • Twitter
    • YouTube
  • ×

    Home » Thanksgiving » The Best Thanksgiving Menu Plan — Including an Elegant Vegetarian Entrée Option

    The Best Thanksgiving Menu Plan — Including an Elegant Vegetarian Entrée Option

    by Beth Lee · Published: Oct 25, 2019 · Modified: Feb 11, 2021

    Creating a Thanksgiving Menu and game plan is a great way to tackle your Thanksgiving or Friendsgiving meal. After years of experience hosting and planning, this post includes my best recipes, tips and tricks to help you create your own traditions for your annual gathering.

    Here is a bonus turkey pot pie recipe for your leftovers.

    Thanksgiving table set with candles and gourds.

    Our Original Thanksgiving Menu…

    It all started with my now tattered copy of The Silver Palate Cookbook by Julee Rosso and Sheila Lukins. My brother and sister-in-law and my now husband and I would trade off Thanksgiving hosting and we always made The Silver Palate turkey and stuffing. Over the years, Thanksgiving became an annual affair in our home and my brother and SIL now host Hanukkah. The recipes have evolved but are still rooted in the originals. Sage sausage in the stuffing, orange flavor with the turkey and a day when calories don’t count and seconds are a must.

    Silver palate cookbook - tattered source of original Thanksgiving menu ideas.

    A Mostly Make-Ahead Stress-Free Thanksgiving Menu with a Vegetarian Option!

    Hosting Thanksgiving can feel overwhelming, but it doesn’t have to. Even if you are an experienced host, having a menu plan will take all the stress out of the preparation. My recipes, tips, tools and tricks will give you confidence so you’re all set to enjoy family and friends on Thanksgiving day.

    We even run/walk a 5K race the morning of Turkey Day and still have everything ready to go by mid afternoon. And you can too!

    3 pairs of running shoes at turkey trot.

    Here’s my general planning calendar that gets me through the process with ease every single year. Sub in your specific recipes and planning details and you’ll reach the Thanksgiving finish line with ease! (double click on the calendar for a printable pdf)

    Thanksgiving planning calendar.

    Thanksgiving Menu Ideas

    From a fantastic vegetarian entree to a fool proof dry brine turkey to all the sides and desserts, my recipes will help you create the Thanksgiving gathering that you want without the stress.

    Turkey, Trimmings and a Vegetarian Menu Idea!

    Everything you need to know about stock, stuffing, turkey plus a main course for the non-turkey eaters!

    Homemade Stuffing Cubes -- A Simple Way to Elevate your Thanksgiving Meal

    Preparing your stuffing cubes couldn't be easier and will make your stuffing taste the best ever!

    Sage Sausage Stuffing with Cornbread and Challah

    We have been making a variation of this stuffing forever! I give you all the instructions you need to have it ready to go the day before so all you have to do is heat on Thanksgiving day.

    How to Make Turkey Stock for your Thanksgiving Feast

    Making your own turkey stock can be done weeks in advance and adds so much flavor to your gravy, stuffing and leftover turkey soup creations!

    How to Dry Brine Turkey for a Stress-Free Thanksgiving

    We tried so many methods - dry brining is the only one that works every time. No mess - by Thanksgiving day, all you have to do is roast the turkey.

    An Elegant Vegetarian Entree for your Holiday Meals

    This Vegetable Wellington will wow your vegetarian guests but your meat-eating diners will love it as well.

    Turkey Pot Pie

    You'll love making this hearty and comforting pot pie with your leftover turkey!

    Side Dishes

    So many ideas of seasonal side dishes to accent your turkey and stuffing.

    How to Cook Green Cauliflower – Roast your Way to Success

    Roasted cauliflower - green, purple, yellow or white - is a simple side dish easily accented with pomegranate seeds to brighten up the table. Can even be made a day ahead and served room temperature.

    Roasted Brussels Sprouts and Cauliflower with Pomegranate Two Ways

    Make this with or without the extra yogurt sauce - pop a few pomegranate seeds on top and it will look stunning on your table!

    Roasted Delicata Squash with Pomegranate Molasses and Date Syrup

    Another make-ahead marvel and remember - you don't have to peel delicata squash!

    Squash Soup Shooters to Toast the Arrival of Fall

    Don't want to serve a soup course? Serve this in little shot glasses as an appetizer. Your guests will think you're brilliant.

    Roasted Butternut Squash Soup with Pomegranate Molasses and Dukkah

    This soup will look gorgeous on your table and it's so easy to make.

    Honey Cornbread with Olive Oil and Sage (Dairy-free option)

    Make this simple cornbread for cubes or to serve alongside your meal.

    Cranberry Orange Jam: A Simple Staple for the Holiday Season

    This is a simple refrigerator jam you can make ahead - serve with the turkey or the day after on sandwiches.

    Pomegranate-Glazed Hasselback Butternut Squash

    Photo Credit: thewimpyvegetarian.com

    This creative dish can serve as a side dish or a main for vegetarians and vegans.

    The Best Dinner Roll Recipe for Thanksgiving (or Whenever)

    Photo Credit: pastrychefonline.com

    If you love to make bread, Jenni's dinner roll recipe will be a wonderful addition to your Thanksgiving feast.

    Crazy Good Mashed Potatoes with Cream Cheese

    Photo Credit: www.fearlessdining.com

    At our house, no matter how many carbs are on the menu, mashed potatoes are a must. This recipe uses cream cheese for an extra level of velvety goodness.

    Pomegranate Cranberry Sauce

    Photo Credit: familyspice.com

    And you all know my love for pomegranates, this cranberry sauce uses pomegranate juice and arils in a simple and delicious version of cranberry sauce.

    The Finishing Touch

    Even though we are all usually too full, dessert is a must and it always includes pie.

    Pie Dough for Dummies -- Top Tips for the Doughaphobic

    Once you master pie crust, you can make any kind of pie you want from pumpkin to pecan to apple. And if I can do it, anyone can.

    The Now Famous Key Lime Pie Recipe -- Perfect Addition to your Holiday Menu

    Sometimes it's nice to make a new tradition. This key lime pie is now a must every year, even though it's not rooted in traditional Thanksgiving fare - it's our family tradition.

    Cranberry Orange Rugelach

    I created this recipe the year that Thanksgiving and Hanukkah overlapped - it's a great way to use that cranberry jam or get ready for holiday cookie parties.

    James Beard's Persimmon Bread: A Perfect Way to Use Hachiya Persimmons

    This persimmon bread came about because I had a plethora of hachiya persimmons. It's a wonderful addition to fall and Thanksgiving flavors. Give it a try!

    This post contains Amazon affiliate links – if you click on one and purchase something, I receive a very tiny percentage of the sale. Your price is never affected. 

    My Favorite Thanksgiving Supplies

    Turkey Brining Bags 

    Photo Credit: www.amazon.com

    These brining bags are perfect to hold your turkey while it dry brines. I've put a 20+ pound turkey in them - sturdy and large. Two to a package.

    All-Clad Stainless Steel 13-Inch x 16-Inch Roaster 

    Photo Credit: www.amazon.com

    I love my All Clad kitchen products (they are not paying me) - durable, even heating and clean up well. This roaster will work for your stock prep and turkey roasting (and so much more all year long.)

    Kizen Instant Read Meat Thermometer 

    Photo Credit: www.amazon.com

    Instant Read Meat Thermometer are the best - I use it all the time and it comes in so handy when you are cooking your turkey. Takes the guesswork out of the process.

    Cuisinart 12-Quart Pasta/Steamer/Stock Pot Set

    Photo Credit: www.amazon.com

    I have an 8 quart pot like this - so versatile. Soups, pasta, steaming veggies, and making stock. If you like to make big batches of stock, I suggest this 12 quart size.

    Nordic Ware Commercial Baker's Half Sheet (2 Pack)

    Photo Credit: www.amazon.com

    I use my half sheet pans almost daily - to bake and to roast. You'll love these for making your stuffing cubes, baking cookies, roasting vegetables and so much more.

    Pyrex Glass Pie Plate (9.5-Inch, 2-Pack)

    Photo Credit: www.amazon.com

    Versatile glass pie plates to use at the holidays and all year long. These are deep dish so plan your dough and filling accordingly.

    Polished Marble Rolling Pin with Wooden Cradle, 10-Inch, White

    Photo Credit: www.amazon.com

    I love my marble rolling pin because it stays cool, which is really helpful for rolling out rugelach dough and pie dough.

    200 Pcs Unbleached Parchment Paper100 Pcs 12x16 Inches Rectangle 100 Pcs 9 Inches Round

    Photo Credit: www.amazon.com

    One of my favorite tools all year in the kitchen is parchment - these pre-cut ones pop right into your sheet pans and the round ones right into your cake or pie pans.

    Oval Turkey Platter

    Photo Credit: www.amazon.com

    We love our inexpensive slightly cheesy turkey platter for serving our turkey - it's just part of our tradition!

    Oval Serving Plates for Parties, 12 Inches, 14 Inches, 15.5 Inches, Set of 3, White

    Photo Credit: www.amazon.com

    I keep it simple and have almost all white plates and serveware. Food looks good on white and it all matches, no matter what color my table setting is.

    Also check out my Amazon shop that includes some of my favorite food and food-related products. I am always updating it – please visit often. And let me know if you need specific products recommendations – I am happy to help!

    The OMG! Yummy Thanksgiving Hotline is open for all of your questions. You can reach me:

    • Leave a comment on this post below
    • Instagram: @omgyummy
    • Facebook: OMG! Yummy

    Buy my cookbook now!

    « Pomegranate Molasses Cocktail: Minty Pomegranate Mule
    Instant Pot Brisket with Pomegranate Molasses »

    Reader Interactions

    Leave a Reply Cancel reply

    Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

    Recipe Rating




    This site uses Akismet to reduce spam. Learn how your comment data is processed.

    Primary Sidebar

    Welcome to OMG! Yummy

    Beth
    Hi! I’m Beth Lee. In 2010, I realized I prefer pita chips to memory chips and started this blog. My family is a mix of Jewish/Hawaiian/Korean heritage and my food reflects our diversity. My virtual kitchen is always open. Let’s cook together!  See all my recipes…

    • Facebook
    • Instagram
    • Pinterest
    • Twitter
    • YouTube

    Buy my cookbook!

    Photo of the cover of the essential Jewish baking cookbook by Beth Lee.

    Sign up for emails & get my Exclusive Preserved Lemon eBook!

    OMG! Yummy Web Stories

    View my web stories

     

    Top Posts

    • Ottolenghi Preserved Lemons: A Tangy, Zippy Must-Have Kitchen Staple
      Ottolenghi Preserved Lemons: A Tangy, Zippy Must-Have Kitchen Staple
    • Kalbi Marinade for Korean Short Ribs
      Kalbi Marinade for Korean Short Ribs
    • Rose Harissa - a Smoky, Spicy Kitchen Condiment with Magical Floral Notes
      Rose Harissa - a Smoky, Spicy Kitchen Condiment with Magical Floral Notes

    Latest

    Close up of shot glass with sangrita in it and a lime wedge.

    Sangrita – What Makes Tequila Completo!

    Various chocolate truffles in a white cupcake container on slate.

    Passover Desserts: Dairy Free Truffles

    Top down view of smoothie in a green glass on a tan plate with a spoon and fresh medjool dates.

    Date smoothie with yogurt and vanilla

    Horizontal image showing logos of various media outlets that OMG! Yummy has been featured in.

    Copyright © 2022 · Beth Lee/OMG! Yummy · All Rights Reserved · Privacy Policy

    • Facebook
    • Pinterest
    • Twitter
    • Yummly
    • Reddit
     

    Loading Comments...